Coles “Down Down” case: what the Federal Court found, and what happens next

Court cases explained · Public-source reporting · ShopHop

Published

Liability found on 13 of 14 sample tickets · penalty not yet decided · ACCC releases rechecked 10 November 2026, 1:25pm Brisbane AEST. Court online files last viewed about 1:00pm that day; the Court site could not be opened at the later check

No penalty-hearing date confirmed from Court sources we could access.

On 14 May 2026 the Federal Court of Australia found that Coles Supermarkets made misleading representations on 13 of the 14 “Down Down” price tickets it examined, in a case brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC). Judgment, para 43; ACCC

The Court has not yet decided any penalty. As at our check on 10 November 2026, no penalty order appeared on the Court’s public file. Court file

What the case was about

The ACCC started the case in September 2024. It alleged that between February 2022 and May 2023 Coles temporarily raised the prices of 245 products, then placed them on “Down Down” promotions at prices that were higher than, or the same as, the prices charged before the increase. Judgment, para 1

“Down Down” tickets usually showed the promotional price next to a smaller “Was” price and date. The ACCC argued shoppers would read that as a genuine discount from a price that had been charged for a reasonable time. Judgment, paras 3–5

Coles disputed the case. It said that during a period of high inflation, suppliers asked for cost price increases. Coles said the higher shelf price that followed was a genuine price, so the later Down Down price was a genuine reduction from it. Judgment, paras 11–14

What the Court decided

To keep the trial manageable, the parties agreed on 12 sample products, two of which were promoted twice, making 14 tickets. All were packaged grocery items, such as soft drink, toothpaste, yoghurt, dog food and paper towels. The case did not concern fresh food. Judgment, paras 15–17

Justice O’Bryan described the issues as “finely balanced”. Judgment, para 36

On several points the Court accepted Coles’ evidence. It found the price increases on the sample products all resulted from supplier cost price increases, that Coles increased prices in a commercially justifiable way, that Coles did not choose artificially high “Was” prices, and that the products sold in commercial volumes at the “Was” price. Judgment, para 39

The deciding issue was time. The Court found that a “Was/now” ticket tells ordinary shoppers that the discount is genuine, which includes the idea that the “Was” price had been charged for a reasonable period. In this setting, the Court concluded the tickets would not have been misleading if the products had been sold at the “Was” price for at least twelve weeks immediately before the promotion. The sample products had typically been at the “Was” price for about four weeks, and sometimes less. Judgment, paras 37–42

On that basis, 13 of the 14 tickets were found to be misleading, in breach of sections 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law. One ticket was not misleading because it did not show a “Was” price. Judgment, paras 43–44

These findings apply to the sample tickets that were tried. They are not a finding that every Down Down promotion, or every one of the 245 products in the ACCC’s case, was misleading.

What each side has said

The ACCC welcomed the decision. “We welcome the Court’s finding that Coles breached the Australian Consumer Law,” ACCC Chair Gina Cass-Gottlieb said. ACCC

Coles said it acknowledged the decision and was reviewing the judgment. A Coles spokesperson pointed to the Court’s finding that the price increases came from supplier cost increases and were commercially justifiable, and called for clear, practical guidance on minimum price establishment periods. ABC News

Has Coles been fined?

Not yet. The ACCC said the Court will determine penalties and other orders at a later date. When it started the case, the ACCC said it would seek declarations, penalties, costs and other orders, including an order that Coles fund a charity to deliver meals. Any penalty is for the Court to decide. ACCC; ACCC, 2024

On 14 May the Court asked the parties for proposed orders for the next stage of the case. As at our check on 10 November 2026, the public file’s newest document was a joint statement of agreed facts dated 6 October 2026. We could not confirm a penalty-hearing date from Court sources, so we are not publishing one. Judgment, orders; Court file

What about the class action?

A separate class action on behalf of shoppers, Demery v Coles, was heard together with the ACCC case on liability. The Court records that the class action is bound by the liability findings made in the ACCC case, subject to appeal rights. Whether any shopper receives compensation, and how much, has not been decided. Judgment, paras 21–26

What this means for shoppers

  • Nothing is owed to you automatically. A civil penalty, if ordered, is paid to the Commonwealth. It is not a refund to shoppers.
  • The ruling is about how long a “Was” price was charged. It did not find that Coles’ price rises in the sample were unjustified.
  • Check the history, not just the ticket. A “Was” price only tells you something useful if the product was really sold at that price for a meaningful time. Price history, unit prices and comparing stores are the practical checks.
  • It does not decide other cases. The separate ACCC case about Woolworths’ “Prices Dropped” promotions is still awaiting judgment, and nothing in this ruling decides it.

What happens next

The Court still has to deal with penalties and other orders, and further steps on the remaining products and the class action. Either side may also have appeal rights. We will update this page when the Court makes new orders, rather than predicting them.

Check prices you can see today

Search groceries on ShopHop to see recorded online price history and unit prices at Woolworths, Coles and Aldi, or compare a basket. Learn how to tell if a special is real and how ShopHop checks “was” prices.

Coverage matters: this article is public-source court reporting. ShopHop did not investigate or detect this conduct, and our price records do not cover 2022–2023. ShopHop tracks advertised online prices at Woolworths, Coles and Aldi; in-store prices can differ. See our methodology.

Related reading: Woolworths “Prices Dropped” case; Perfection Fresh and ALDI supplier case; Separate case: Coles’ Kalgoorlie Tribunal hearing (a merger review).

Neutral public-source reporting, not legal advice. Allegations and submissions are attributed and are not findings unless the Court made them.

Frequently asked questions

Has Coles been fined over Down Down?

No. As at our check on 10 November 2026 we found no penalty order; the ACCC says penalties will be decided later. Sources: S2, S3.

Did the Court find every Down Down price was misleading?

No. It examined 14 tickets for 12 sample packaged products and found 13 misleading. Sources: S1.

Why misleading if the price rises were justified?

The Court accepted the rises came from supplier costs, but the “Was” price had applied too briefly (typically about four weeks). It considered that tickets would not have been misleading had the “Was” price applied for at least twelve weeks. Sources: S1.

Will shoppers get money back?

Not automatically. Penalties go to the Commonwealth, and class-action compensation is undecided. Sources: S1.

Does this decide the Woolworths case?

No. It is a separate case, and judgment is reserved. Sources: S2. Woolworths explainer.

Sources

ShopHop is independent and not affiliated with Woolworths, Coles or Aldi. Prices are collected from publicly accessible supermarket websites and reflect online prices; in store prices may differ. Promotions analysis gets stronger as the 90-day evidence window fills. Indicators are informational and do not constitute legal findings.

Prices shown are sourced from publicly visible online listings and may not reflect current in-store prices. Data is refreshed regularly. Learn more about ShopHop and our price data

Coles Down Down court ruling explained | ShopHop