Coles’ Kalgoorlie challenge: what the Tribunal is hearing and what happens next
Competition explained · Public-source reporting · ShopHop
Published
Hearing under way · decision pending · checked 10 November 2026, 8:10am Brisbane AEST
Hearing listed 9–12 and 16–20 November 2026. Dates can change.
Coles has begun its challenge to the competition watchdog’s decision to block a proposed second Coles supermarket in Kalgoorlie-Boulder. The Australian Competition Tribunal began hearing the case in Melbourne on Monday 9 November 2026. No decision has been made, and none is expected on a hearing day. Tribunal listing; Tribunal case file
It is the first application for Tribunal review under Australia’s new merger approval system. Tribunal reasons, para 15
What Coles wants to build
Coles wants to lease a vacant site in Somerville, Kalgoorlie-Boulder, for a full-line supermarket of about 2,800 square metres and a Liquorland store. This is a proposed new development. It is not a plan to buy O’Connor Fresh IGA or any other existing store. ACCC register
The ACCC decided on 30 June 2026 that the proposal must not go ahead and published that decision on 1 July. Coles then applied to the Tribunal for review in July 2026. The case is ACT 1 of 2026; the ACCC reference is MN-01068. ACCC register; Tribunal reasons
Why the ACCC said no
The ACCC accepted that a new Coles would bring some benefits, including a new store and some short-term response from rivals. However, it assessed a material risk that the store would take enough sales from O’Connor Fresh IGA for that independent store to close without timely replacement. It concluded shoppers would be worse off over time through the loss of a differentiated local offer, such as local products, longer trading hours and customer service. ACCC reasons, paras 8.4–8.9 (PDF) The Tribunal’s reasons describe O’Connor Fresh IGA as the closest supermarket to the proposed site. Tribunal reasons, para 4
These are the regulator’s assessments, not Tribunal findings, and they are disputed.
What Coles argued on day one
Coles’ barrister, John Sheahan, opened Coles’ case on Monday, according to reports by The West Australian and MLex. He argued the new store would add rivalry and choice. “This kind of investment increases consumer choice, increases rivalry and so does not reduce competition,” he said, as reported by The West Australian. The West Australian
MLex reported he argued that the ACCC’s approach would make the regulator or the Tribunal the judge of what consumers should prefer, rather than letting competition reveal those preferences. Lawyerly reported Coles’ position that independent supermarkets should not be insulated from competition. MLex; Lawyerly
In its October written submissions, Coles disputes that O’Connor Fresh IGA is likely to close. It also argues that, without predatory or similar conduct, a rival losing customers to a new store is not harm to competition. Coles submissions, paras 1–4 (PDF) Coles has also said Kalgoorlie’s growth and fly-in, fly-out workforce support another supermarket. ABC
What the ACCC and O’Connor Fresh IGA say
The day-one reports we could access focused on Coles’ opening. The positions below come from public documents filed before the hearing.
The ACCC says Coles is taking too narrow an approach. In the ACCC’s view, no finding of predatory conduct is needed. A new store can substantially lessen competition if it is likely to remove an effective independent rival that will not be replaced. ACCC contentions, paras 2–5 and 9 (PDF)
O’Connor Fresh IGA, an intervener in the review, says it is a profitable, differentiated store that would remain so without the new Coles. It also says closure is its likely outcome if the new store opens. Coles disputes this. IGA submissions, paras 1–10 (PDF)
A September Tribunal ruling on evidence noted Coles’ submission that this theory of harm is relatively new in Australian merger law. The same ruling rejected Coles’ complaint that the theory had not been disclosed. It did not decide whether the store may go ahead. Tribunal reasons, paras 97 and 108
Which supermarkets are already there?
The ACCC identified six supermarkets: Coles, Woolworths, Spudshed, O’Connor Fresh IGA, Hannans Marketplace by FoodWorks and IGA Lionel St. The first four are full-line. It did not include an operating ALDI. Coles’ two older stores closed when its CBD store opened in 2021. ACCC reasons (PDF); ABC
What this means for shoppers
- Nothing changes at the checkout today. The hearing does not set prices, open or close stores, or change trading hours.
- The new Coles cannot proceed while the ACCC’s decision stands. Even an approval would not mean a store opens straight away. We have not verified any construction timetable.
- The question is choice over time. The two sides disagree on whether a second Coles adds competition or eventually removes an independent alternative. Price matters, but so do range, opening hours and service.
- No-one can promise a price effect on any shopper’s bill.
- It matters beyond Kalgoorlie. As the first review under the new merger rules, its reasons will likely be read closely. They will not decide every future case.
Nationally, the ACCC’s 2025 inquiry estimated that Woolworths held 38% and Coles 29% of supermarket grocery sales. These are not Kalgoorlie figures. Inquiry report
What happens next
The hearing is listed for 9–12 and 16–20 November 2026, starting at 9:15am Brisbane AEST. The panel is Justice O’Bryan, Dr Ray Steinwall and Professor David Byrne. Listings can change. Tribunal listing
The Tribunal can affirm, set aside or vary the ACCC’s decision within statutory time limits. Those limits can be extended, and a 60-day extension has already been made. No decision date has been announced, and the last hearing day is not a decision date. Tribunal reasons, paras 3, 5 and 23–25
We will update this page after the hearing, and again after checking the published decision, rather than predicting who will win.
Compare the prices you can check today
Search groceries on ShopHop to check unit prices and compare recorded online prices at Woolworths, Coles and Aldi. For a basket view, compare common items. New to this? Read unit pricing explained and how to compare grocery prices.
Coverage matters: this article is not a Kalgoorlie price survey. ShopHop does not cover every local supermarket, including independents. Online prices and availability can differ from your local store or checkout. Confirm with the retailer and read our methodology.
Neutral public-source reporting, not legal advice. Submissions and regulator assessments are attributed to the people who made them and are not findings.
Frequently asked questions
Did the Tribunal decide anything on day one?
No. The first day was for submissions, and no decision was announced. The Tribunal case file showed no new orders or decision when we checked on 10 November 2026 (Brisbane AEST). Sources: S5.
Is Coles buying O’Connor Fresh IGA?
No. The proposal is a lease at a vacant site for a new Coles supermarket and Liquorland. Whether the new store would lead O’Connor Fresh IGA to close is one of the disputed questions in the case. Sources: S1, S6.
Why would another supermarket reduce competition?
A new store can add choice at first. In their written filings, the ACCC and O’Connor Fresh IGA argue that, in this local market, it could lead to an independent rival closing and not being replaced, leaving less competitive pressure over time. Coles argues that this would just be the result of shoppers choosing between stores, and that the new store adds competition. The Tribunal will decide. Sources: S3, S10, S11, S12.
When will the decision come out?
No date has been announced. The hearing is listed until 20 November 2026. The Tribunal must decide within statutory time limits, which can be extended, and one 60-day extension has already been made. Sources: S4, S6.
Does ShopHop show Kalgoorlie supermarket prices?
No. This article is not a Kalgoorlie price survey. ShopHop tracks advertised online prices at Woolworths, Coles and Aldi, not every local retailer. Prices and availability can vary, so confirm with the retailer before you buy. Methodology.
Sources
- S1 ACCC acquisitions register, MN-01068
- S3 ACCC Statement of Reasons, public version, 30 June 2026 (PDF)
- S4 Australian Competition Tribunal, home page and hearing listing
- S5 Tribunal case file, ACT 1 of 2026
- S6 Tribunal reasons on evidence, [2026] ACompT 1, 24 September 2026
- S8 ACCC supermarkets inquiry final report, 21 March 2025
- S10 Coles written submissions, public version, 16 October 2026 (PDF)
- S11 ACCC amended concise statement of contentions, public version, 15 October 2026 (PDF)
- S12 O’Connor Fresh IGA written submissions, public version, 25 October 2026 (PDF)
- S14 The West Australian, Cheyanne Enciso, 9 November 2026 (subscription)
- S15 MLex, Saloni Sinha, 9 November 2026 (subscription)
- S16 Lawyerly, Andy Sidler, 9 November 2026 (subscription)
- S18 ABC News, 1 July 2026